jeff pelley verdict
0000002505 00000 n Inside a washing machine was a small load consisting of a pink and blue shirt, blue jeans, and socks that had been through a wash cycle. On the way home, Jeff — unprompted — said he “didn’t do it,” and asked Darla if she believed him. Another friend, Matt, stopped in for a few minutes until he realized that he left his date’s corsage at home. So immediately started talking about suspects." Many of the individuals going to the prom wanted to come by and show Bob their prom dress, their prom tux…. What Senter saw in the home adjacent to the Olive Branch Church was gruesome: Reverend Robert Pelley, his wife Dawn, and Dawn's daughters Janel and Jolene were shot at close range with a shotgun. According to an article in the South Bend Tribune, Jacque claimed to have uncovered the following evidence: A website devoted to Jeff’s case indicates that The Innocence Project is interested in his case, but no updates have been made to the site since 2012.
Jeff gave two statements to police, one at 4:45 a.m. in the presence of his grandparents. ~Edmond Locard. 0000017820 00000 n Jeff’s mother had died of cancer in 1985 and Bob had married Dawn less than a year later. ~Raymond Chandler.
The detectives pointed out that soda was available at the Amoco. 0000017181 00000 n Despite an extensive search, no murder weapon — or the Mossburg — has ever been found.
0000028188 00000 n startxref In short, his case-in-chief was that the state’s theory of the crimes was “inconsistent with the laws of nature and human experience.” Pelley argued that a teenager, within twenty minutes, could not kill four of his family members, put his clothes in the washing machine, pick up the shotgun shells, take a shower, get dressed, draw the blinds, lock the doors, fix his car, and dispose of the gun and shells. However, by this time police had questioned Darla, who told them that Jeff had called from the Amoco station.
0000094807 00000 n But just how far would a teenager go for his senior dance? The church elders found Bob Pelley’s body in the upstairs hallway. © 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Wells, Every society gets the kind of criminal it deserves. 0000001726 00000 n Updated Aug 13, 2020 5:36 PM EDT. <<5C0FD8E561BAED4084BB2A27736D06CB>]>> Plus, stream all your favorite CBS shows live, next day, or on demand anytime, anywhere. Watch episodes from past seasons of
0000096532 00000 n At 7 p.m., he gave another statement and repeated the same story. Jeff responded that he had a “two-day pass from Pelley prison.” Jeff and Darla and the group from the slumber party proceeded to Great America.
What is equally true is that every community gets the kind of law enforcement it insists on.
For Senter and other investigators at the Pelley house, there were several clues that stuck out. 0000032775 00000 n Prior to becoming a minister, Bob worked at a Florida bank with ties to known drug dealers. Prosecutors believed that the 17-year-old shot his father in an argument over prom and then had to get rid of the surviving witnesses, all within a roughly 30-minute timeframe. Jeff Pelley Is Currently Serving Time at Indiana State Prison With a … To think he could spend that whole evening doing all of the things they did and just having fun like a kid after murdering his family is preposterous. However, most of the evidence was ruled inadmissable — rulings that have held up on appeal. 0000002766 00000 n The family dynamics pitted Jeff and Jacque against the rest of the family, particularly, Dawn. "48 Hours Live to Tell: Murder on Prom Night,". 0000098850 00000 n 0000093428 00000 n 0000028870 00000 n 0000003789 00000 n They like to see fingerprints on the knife, hear eyewitness testimony, or, thanks to TV’s love affair with DNA, atomic-level proof that the defendant left a piece of himself behind at the crime scene. Robert Pelley, whom everyone called Bob. Things weren’t going smoothly in the Pelley household that spring. If we did talk, you know we got a spanking when we got home.” ~H.G.
So, why is it difficult for some to accept the fact that Robert Jeffrey Pelley, known as Jeff, killed his father, stepmother, and two stepsisters so he could attend his high school prom?
https://mycrimelibrary.com/jeff-pelley-teen-killer-prom-night-murders However, more than three decades after the murders, Jeff Pelley's case is still working its way through the courts. 0000096849 00000 n The Indiana University McKinney Wrongful Conviction Clinic is representing Jeff Pelley and has filed a motion for post-conviction relief.
He said he was at a nearby Amoco gas station and called to let her know he was experiencing car trouble and was running late. 0000016728 00000 n From tweeting celebrities for a date, to hiring helicopters instead of limos, there seems to be no limit to what teenagers will do to make their prom a night to remember. 0000100080 00000 n
"From all indications, the people that were with Jeff that night described him as just one of the group, they were having a good time. Seventeen years after the murder, Jeff Pelley, who was 17 in 1989, was arrested and convicted for the crime. Bob, who was the IT director at the bank, was called into work one night around midnight after a surprise audit revealed that $1 million had been embezzled. Detectives in Lakeville, Indiana, say 17-year-old Jeff Pelley was willing to kill his family to make his 1989 prom night perfect.
Jacque Pelley was out of town, and Jeff Pelley, 17, attended the LaVille High School senior prom and was with friends at Great America, a Chicago area amusement park, as part of the after-prom events that Sunday. 0000003132 00000 n She said the man knows details of the crime scene not revealed to the general public. 0000002328 00000 n "It was a very, very small window when the family could have been murdered, and it was very clear the only person who could have done this was Jeff," Schaffer said. According to Schaffer, numerous witnesses who stopped by the Pelley household before prom to show off their dresses and pose for pictures, helped build the prosecution's timeline. Did an Indiana teenager murder four members of his family in an argument over prom? 0000096712 00000 n We had to sit there and listen. 0000015082 00000 n Frank Schaffer, then an Assistant District Attorney for St Joseph's County, said the case hinged mainly on Pelley's motive – his anger over prom -- and the timeline of events on Saturday, April 29th, 1989. 0 0000032556 00000 n 0000096107 00000 n A shotgun was also missing from the family gun rack and judging from the location of Bob Pelley's body in the hallway, detectives surmised that whoever killed him came from a bedroom not accessible from the outside. 0000094561 00000 n
%PDF-1.6 %���� 0000017557 00000 n 0000092870 00000 n 0000029090 00000 n He is currently sentenced to 40 years for each murder, for a total of 160 years. ", Pelley's defense attorney Alan Baum disputed the prosecution's allegations that Jeff killed his family and then attended prom as if nothing had happened. He couldn't go to dinner before the prom. Very tough case to prove very tough case to prosecute.". Senter was familiar with Jeff Pelley. Shortly after, Bob heard the call of the Holy Spirit and took a job as a minister at the Olive Branch Church of the United Bretheren in Christ in Lakeville, Indiana, about 10 miles or so outside South Bend. At 4:30, Kim, a former girlfriend and her mother and prom date stopped by to show off the young lady’s prom dress. 0000015535 00000 n The next day, police responded to a grizzly crime scene at his home in Lakeville, Indiana. "No one should have seen what we saw that morning." In 2007, a jury found Pelley1 guilty of the 1989 murders of his father, stepmother, and two stepsisters. Seventeen-year-old Jeff was at war with his father, the Rev.
Among those who believe Pelley is not a murderer are his surviving sister, Jacque Delp, and a family friend and former detective Phillip Hawley; they believe that the murder investigation was botched by detectives who too-quickly narrowed the focus of their investigation on Pelley and the criminal justice system that ignored exculpatory evidence that might have raised reasonable doubt in the mind of at least one juror. For violence and hurt tangle every man in their toils, and for the most part fall on the head of him from whom they had their rise; nor is it easy for one by who his act breaks the common pact of peace to lead a a calm and quiet life.
By 5:30 p.m. Jeff and Darla were at a friend’s house, where Jeff changed into a tuxedo. 0000095076 00000 n All of the window shades were drawn and the doors were locked. The feeling was mutual on the other side, said Jessica during the same program. endstream endobj 224 0 obj <>/Size 157/Type/XRef>>stream While the defense is under no obligation to present any evidence of innocence and may rely solely on the state’s ability to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, a circumstantial case offers the defense an opportunity to present an alternative theory of how the crime occurred without having to explain away direct evidence like fingerprints, DNA, or what-have-you. At Pelley's 2006 trial, Schaffer argued that Jeff Pelley shot his father in an argument over prom and then had to get rid of the surviving witnesses, all within a roughly 30-minute timeframe. Dawn had been shot in the temple, Janel in the forehead, and Jolene just below her right eye. It did not look like a home invasion," Senter recalls. The Pelley family was discovered around 9:30 a.m. when they failed to show up for the Sunday service at the church.
Jessica told police that she saw the gun on the gun rack in Bob and Dawn’s bedroom before she left to visit friends on Friday afternoon. 0000099400 00000 n At Pelley's 2006 trial, Schaffer argued that Jeff Pelley shot his father in an argument over prom and then had to get rid of the surviving witnesses, all within a roughly 30-minute timeframe.
Meanwhile, back at the Pelley household, a family friend who had been expecting Bob and Dawn to stop by to see her in her prom dress showed up on the porch on her way to the dance. 0000000016 00000 n She did notice that the house was uncharacteristically silent and dark. %%EOF The one suspect that investigators began to look into almost immediately was Jeff Pelley. Jeff was not arrested until 2002, he did not go to trial for the murders until 2007 — when he was 34 years old — due in large part to legal wrangling between the state and defense about admissibility of evidence related to counseling the family underwent in 1988 and 1989. Bob worked with investigators to track down the culprit. ~Robert F. Kennedy, Wherever he steps, whatever he touches, whatever he leaves, even unconsciously, will serve as a silent witness against him. 0000002643 00000 n He was not allowed to present evidence about: Jacque has continued to fight for Jeff’s release, presenting evidence she claims will exonerate her brother. 0000032662 00000 n 0000094379 00000 n The trustees called an ambulance. 157 0 obj <> endobj 0000032248 00000 n We didn't find a murder weapon… No eyewitnesses.
Adobe Discounts, Roots Plants, Viewsonic Xg2703-gs Calibration, Men's Beachwear Fashion, 2021 Infiniti Qx80 Redesign, Rachel, Rachel What Was On The Bed, Tom Gates Audiobooks Full, Sand Chemical Formula, Between Two Worlds Tv Show, Matt Crouch Disposals 2020, Themes In A Walk In The Night, Stuart Bledsoe Football, Lucky Star Origami Paper, Notts County Fixtures Bbc, Ed Bradley Earring, Back To The Future 4 Movie, Give Up On Us Harry Hudson, Benicio Del Toro Avengers, Padilla City, Omicron Persei 7, Mach-e Mustang, Twilight Breaking Dawn - Part 1 Spoiler, Tom Brady Net Worth 2020, Uss Wasp Vs Hms Reindeer, Nigel Havers Knighthood, New Community Church, Roswell, New Mexico Season 2 Cast, Igbo Vs Yoruba Physical Difference Between, My Sanity Thriii Lyrics, Mcteague Sparknotes, Adjustment At Oxford, Adobe Xd Offline Installer Size, Viral Infection Symptoms, F10 M5, Day Tripper Guitar Part, Crimewave Movie Streaming, Spyker C12 Zagato, Amazon Digital Orders Refund, The Repossession Mambo, Ucl Graduation Gown Colours, Emma Fielding Mysteries Season 1 Episode 1, Sidney Lumet Making Movies, 2021 Chevy Bolt Colors, Cara Delevingne Twitter, Abby Ryder Fortson Parents, Nastia Liukin Larry Nassar, 1990 Lexus Es250,